Font Size
Join our Mailing List
Home The needs of the few outweigh those of the many

Unless the 300-yard driver for 85-mph swings comes along, Barney Adams has some ideas how the game can be more fun for those that pay for the experience. He believes it’s vital for the long-term health and welfare of the game. “There are lots of issues to be addressed in the industry, I'm a huge fan of junior programs, caddies, family friendly courses initiatives, at the local level too numerous to mention,” Adams said. “I am zeroing in on one specific aspect of participation because if we ignore that, if we keep doing the same things we've done in the past the prognostication for the future is very unhealthy. I have no illusions about the difficulty involved to bring about this change,” he continued.

“Good business practices teach us to be very focused in our marketing efforts. The golf industry has data that identifies the target market but somehow the message of focused marketing gets lost,” said the founder of Adams Golf. “‘Come play our magnificent 7,200 yard (famous designer) layout.’ At 7,200 yards you are marketing to maybe 2% of your potential customers. When golfers do arrive they are not allowed to play from 7,200 yards but moved forward as if they aren't worthy. So we've accomplished two things: spending advertising dollars ineffectively and creating a negative environment once customers get on property,” Adams explained. “And here's the odd part: I don't fault the owners/operators for this. They are responding to a culture developed over the years that emphasizes course length not shots into the green.”

Many smart people have come to work in golf throughout the years after enjoying success in other walks of life. However, golf isn’t like many other industries. It’s an enigma. “To start let me be clear, you cannot put golf in a defined box. One of the great joys of the game is its inconsistency; you can have two 360-yard par 4 holes that play completely different. Fairway slopes, prevailing winds, types of grass hazards to avoid and I could go on. So analyze in golf terms, the way holes play, not in absolute yardages. No better example exists than the recent U.S. Open at Merion. I loved watching the best players in the world trying to hit short par 4 greens from the rough or, even the fairway, and you know what? Sometimes they didn't !” Adams said.

This is where Adams, the engineer, begins to explain the distance issue that is hurting golf. “I use men's data simply because it's more familiar and easier for me to write about; I have women's data as well,” he said. “ Fig 1 shows a classic long par 4, 460 yards, with a trap protecting the right side of the green. This is pretty basic architecture. Data from the PGA Tour's Shotlink system on 35,000 drives shows that Tour players will hit 6 or 7 irons into the green 26% of the time, an 8 iron 36% of the time and 9 irons or wedges 22% of the time. There will be roughly 40 yards between the longest and shortest drives. This is why 7,200 yards is no problem for Tour players, who constitute .08% of those who play. Please allow me to emphasize: the .08% are great talents who play a game that is television entertainment. Somehow the folks who are protecting the game get them mixed up with the other 99.92% -us,” he said.

“For amateurs, who cares?! Using data from 1.8 million handicaps, fewer than 10% of players will get home to the aforementioned green in two shots using any club; stick a creek in front of the green, making it a forced carry, and the GIR figure drops to less than 6%,” he continued. “ Aha! A poor example, you say, because amateurs don't often play 460-yard par 4 holes. I'll agree, but even under Tee It Forward they will play 405-yard par 4's. From that distance all of the Tour players, if they hit driver or three wood off the tee, will hit 9 iron or wedge into the green on their second shots. The number of amateurs getting home in two on a 405-yard par 4 leaps all the way to 24%, and to 15% with that damn creek to carry. That carefully sculpted trap on the right might work better as a grass bunker because even in that at 24%, many are rolling the ball onto the green, not hitting a soft shot to a protected pin.  

“So it isn't about forward tees, it's about where you play approach shots from. On Tour the average iron into a par 4 hole is an 8 iron and that's good enough for me. I mean my 8-iron, which goes 135 not theirs, which goes 164-yards on average. How can I correctly emphasize this? Not one hole but 8 irons or less for most second shots. Play the same type of shots into the green that the best players in the world do. Most golfers play the equivalent of a 12' basket (in basketball terms). Many decades ago I cleaned clubs and it stuck with me that the long irons were seldom used, a thought that ultimately led to the design of a fairway wood. Cleaning clubs today and I'd see used hybrids and relatively clean 6-9 irons!”      

Interestingly, Tom Fazio, renowned golf course architect stated,  "The golf industry should pay very close attention to Barney's ideas. The game should be fun, not a struggle."

“Install me as Grand Czar and all courses would be required to have markers measured 135 yards from the green,” Adams said, tongue in cheek. “They could be painted sprinkler heads, small plaques, trees like the old 150 bushes. The markers are reminders. It's like having a great Scottish caddy standing in the fairway, ‘Aye, Laddie play from here. It's just like the professionals only adjusted for you.’ He will explain there is a 40-yard spread-plus or minus 20 yards-from the markers and playing within that spread is to play the same shots Tour players do. Over a relatively short period, the question of what tees to play will become evident. The back tees don't disappear; they just get used by the few that really belong there.

“Originally I had this grand idea of official markers sanctioned by the PGA of America and the USGA. The regional PGA of America staff would verify them as they visited courses. This would allow certified facilities to advertise that they featured the chance to play Tour-type shots into the greens, have fun, and enjoy the game. I even invented a sponsor who would host a three-year amateur event played from the correct distances. Like a lot of my grand schemes, reality intervened. The USGA and PGA of America have their own programs.

“Truth is I harbor a dream of a large corporation with ties to golf contacting me about wanting to be associated with an event that so strongly supports amateur golf. Oh Golf Channel and a partner, can you hear me, televised regionals, finals; this would be a game changer. Nope, not looking for work here, just trying to help.”